Return of the Fall Pie
October 30th, 2008I am back after a long hiatus. I had a baby last October and I can’t think of any other or better explanation as to why you have not heard from me. Now that she is an adorable toddler, I have just enough time to try to post more regularly.
In the fall every year, before Thanksgiving, at the height of apple and quince season I crave pie. Often what really pushes me over the edge into pie making mode is the mid-October menu change at Chanterelle, when Empire apples become available, and I make a roast, stuffed apple dish with them. Empire apples are abundant at the farmers markets in the New York area starting in mid-October and they resemble a macintosh but have a brighter red skin with a heartier, sweeter flesh that stays crisp longer and also holds up better in the cooking process.
We core and then roast the Empire apples in the oven, removing the flesh once it separates from the skin and saving the skin as vessel to hold the apple filling once we have seasoned it and sauteed it on the stove. I cook the apples with brown butter, vanilla bean and diced dried calimyrna figs. Once sauteed, these cooked apples are irresistible. I eat the filling every day as it sits on trays waiting to be stuffed back in the Empire apple skins.
As I delight in the flavor of these apples I think about pie and my family. I want them to experience this apple filling but I also want what pie does to this filling. Pie seals these flavors, melts them, tenderizes them, enriches them and surrounds them with an ethereal flaky pastry.
Pie is not something I serve at the restaurant for two reasons. The first is that most of our desserts are individual self contained portions — we would have to make an entire four inch pie for each dessert plate. And these small pies, while they can look adorable, have too much crust in proportion to filling. The crust does not brown and bake well. The second reason has to do with my own feelings about pie and pies produced in large quantities. Good pie is a seemingly simple dessert. But it takes so much love and care in the preparing and cooking process to produce pie with taste and texture. Pie is a balance between a sweet, soft, textured, fruity, tart, creamy filling and a crisp, delicate, flavorful crust. From my years in the kitchen both at home with family and at the restaurant, this balance is hard to achieve when making large quantities of pie.
So if you like baked fruit pie, as I do, try these recipes and make a pie or a couple of pies for family and friends in the fall months before or around Thanksgiving. This apple pie has a large quantity of crisp fall Empire and Golden Delicious apples seasoned with brown butter, vanilla bean, a little fig — but no cinnamon — all of which are sauteed on the stove to reduce water content, concentrating flavor and requiring very little starch to bind the baked filling. The apple slices are cooked in the pie pastry until they are soft, succulent and syrupy but maintain their integrity. Serve the pie warm with a dollop of creme fraiche, whipped cream or vanilla ice cream.
This pie was recently featured in Time Out New York.
Empire and Golden Delicious Apple Pie Filling
3 1/2 pounds of apples (I like empire and golden delicious or a mix of the two)
4 oz. butter
1 vanilla bean
4 dried figs
1/2 cup + 3 tablespoons sugar
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 tablespoon flour
Garnish for Crust
1 egg
1 tablespoon sugar
pinch of cinnamon
See my post on pie crust for recipe and directions for the crust. The dough must be made at least 2 hours before rolling and baking the pie. It can be made up to three days in advance if you refrigerate the dough and a month in advance if you freeze the dough.
Peel the apples and remove the cores. With a chefs knife, slice the apples as thinly as possible. Chop the figs up finely. In a good stainless steel coated aluminum saute pan, over high heat (on a home stove), melt 2 oz. of butter with half the vanilla bean, its seeds and half the chopped figs. Just as the butter browns, add half the sliced apples and 1/4 teaspoon salt. Cook for a minute stirring with a wooden spoon to make sure all the apples are coated with some butter. Add 1/4 cup of sugar and continue to cook, stirring every two minutes. The juices from the apples will be released into the pan. Cook the apples on high heat until all the juices evaporate and you have a slight vanilla syrup left in the pan. The apples should look cooked but not caramelized and dry. Allow this mixture to cool while you repeat the same steps with the remaining half of the apples. Once you have cooked all the apples, allow them to cool on two plates until they have come to room temperature. Once the apples have cooled somewhat begin rolling the dough and preheat the oven.
Right before you place the apples into the pie crust mix them with the remaining 3 tablespoons of sugar and the 1 tablespoon of flour.
Roll the dough out after your fruit is cooked and already at room temperature. Preheat your oven to 400. On a cool, dry counter surface, roll one piece of dough out until it is almost 1/16” thick and forms a rough 14” circle. Drape it into your pie pan and press it into the pan so that it covers the bottom and sides. Trim the edge of the dough so that it hangs over the edge by 1”.
Roll your second piece of dough out into a circle with a thickness of 1/16” also. Add your finished pie filling to the pie and cover it with the second piece of dough. Trim this dough so it hangs over the edge by 1/2”. Fold the bottom dough over the top and press two layers together on the rim of the pie plate. Once you have pressed the entire seem together, press your thumb and forefinger together on both hands. Use your pressed finger tips on both hands to surround a section of the seem and squeeze so that the dough between your left and right hand fingers forms a peak. Repeat this process, pressing and squeezing around the rim of the pie, making a decorative pattern while sealing your dough.
Whisk an egg with 1 teaspoon of water. Using a pastry brush lightly paint the entire top crust including the decorative edge. Mix a pinch of cinnamon into 1 tablespoon of sugar and dust the top of your pie with the sugar. With a sharp paring knife, make a five evenly spaced slits, one inch long coming out from the center of the pie. These slits serve as steam holes for the filling as it bakes. Place the pie in a 400 degree still oven (no fan) on the bottom shelf for 1/2 hour and then bake for another 1/2 to 1 hour at 350. Total baking time will vary with your oven. Make sure the crust is a deep golden brown and the filling is bubbling — steam is rising from your air vents — before removing it from the oven. Serve warm and Enjoy.

Another fall menu item that compels me to make pie is Quince. A case of quince perfumes our entire walk in refrigerator; four quince in a bowl on my counter at home scents my entire dining area. At the restaurant, we make quince jam for our cheese plate, quince compote, quince sorbet, individual quince and apple tarts. At home, in addition to having some quince jam with cheese or foie gras terrine, I love to add it to pie. It is a bit too intense to stand alone in pie. But cooked slowly with butter and sugar, with its rusty rose color, naturally pectin rich syrup, and earthy, sweet, floral flavor it blends beautifully with apples in pie.
Apple and Quince Pie Filling
3 ripe medium quince (approx. 1# 8 oz.)
3/4 cup water
3/4 cup + 6 tablespoons sugar
3 oz. butter
1 lb. 12 oz. apples ( approx. 5 apples)
1 vanilla bean
pinch of salt
1 T. flour
Rub the naturally occurring fuzz off the quince with a dry rag. Peel the quince, setting aside the peels. Stand the fruit up and slice the flesh off the core in four sections, making sure to leave all seeds in the core section. Set aside the flesh and chop the core into four pieces. Place the chopped cores and the peels in a small pot with 3/4 cup of water and 1/2 cup of sugar. Simmer on low for one hour. Run the simmered fruit and peels with the syrupy liquid through a food mill or ricer. Discard the seeds and hard pieces that remain.
Chop the flesh of the quince into small 1/8-1/4 inch cubes. Simmer the cubed fruit with the quince syrup and add an additional 1/4 cup of sugar and an ounce of butter. Simmer fruit mixture for an hour until the quince is completely tender and has attained a rusty orange color. Allow this quince mixture to cool completely. Mix this with the cooled apple filling and bake the pie or reserve it in the refrigerator (up to one week) until you are ready to make the pie.
Peel the apples. Slice the flesh off the core in four sections and discard the peels and cores. Using a chef’s knife, slice the apples as thinly as possible. Preheat a medium saute pan and brown 2 oz. butter with the pod and seeds of the vanilla bean. Add the apples cook for a minute stirring with a wooden spoon to make sure all the apples are coated with some butter. Add 3 tablespoons of sugar and continue to cook, stirring every two minutes. The juices from the apples will be released into the pan. Cook the apples on high heat until all the juices evaporate and you have a slight vanilla syrup left in the pan. The apples should look cooked but not caramelized and dry.
Allow the apple mixture to cool. You can store the apples for a day in the refrigerator. Right before filling the pie, mix the cooked apples, the cooked quince, 3 tablespoons of sugar and 1 tablespoon of flour together in a bowl. Follow the instructions above for rolling out pie dough, filling the pie and baking the pie.





























RSS Feeds